Lynch sketches out variations on familiar themes mdash;multiple personalities, mysterious beings, time warps, sexual paranoia mdash;and gives them a somewhat coherent tone through the subconscious buzz of ironic pop songs (Little Eva rsquo;s ldquo;The Locomotion, rdquo; Nina Simone rsquo;s ldquo;Sinner Man rdquo;).
) The film rsquo;s gloomy title is an art-student rsquo;s invitation to project: Come visit unreachable, far-off places; journey through someone else rsquo;s egotistical labyrinth. As Dern rsquo;s Nikki disintegrates into her newest film role as Sue, the adulterous murder mystery may possibly reflect back on Nikki rsquo;s own professional and private crises. Still, Inland Empire must be taken in a relaxed attitude as Lynch rsquo;s in-joke, a psychotic, Bosch-like doodle.
It seems designed to confound newcomers as much as to delight devotees.
This was a bad decision. Frankly, it looks like crap. Artist that he is, Lynch hasn rsquo;t solved the problem of video rsquo;s fluctuating, out-of-register skin tones or the general problem of visual murk.
He wants to hijack movie audiences and take them to the lesser realm of gallery installations and home-sketchpad-digital whimsies. But does the willingness of critics to gallery-hop make our film culture more sophisticated than in periods of truly revolutionary and controversial film aesthetics? Are we smarter because we don rsquo;t question Lynch rsquo;s confounding mannerisms the way critics once foolishly scoffed at Alain Resnais rsquo; magnificent Last Year at Marienbad or Ingmar Bergman rsquo;s Persona?
The real enigma of Inland Empire is how it seduces critics who ignored Juli a n Hern a ndez rsquo;s very beautiful and artful Broken Sky; they lack the confidence to see what rsquo;s wrong when Lynch is simply being wacky as in Wild at Heart, Lost Highway and Twin Peaks: Fire Walk With Me.
This achievement was equal to Dickens or Griffith, yet Lynch stayed obstinately unconventional. That he balked at the pop side of his talent became evident in the way Fire Walk with Me, a sequel/prequel to the Twin Peaks series but devised for theatrical distribution, distended and weakened the series rsquo; greatness. The mix of TV simplicity and cinematic ambiguity found in ldquo;Twin Peaks rdquo; explored pop formats, national secrets about families, the specter of sin, the lure of death, the guilt of sex, the innocence of romance and the undercurrent of madness and violence in human beings that goes against nature and produces a cosmic void.
Critics expect DePalma to follow Hollywood narrative conventions despite his constant subversion of them, while Lynch is permitted to make capital-A art. Fact is, Inland Empire rsquo;s conceptual obscurities are less enthralling than the latest DePalma and Barney.
His somber ironies about Hollywood expose the superstitions and biases of different classes and assorted competing egos. Nikki rsquo;s freakouts on street corners seem symptomatic of some social malaise that Lynch sketches with great command and confidence. But Dern represented sexual Americana more memorably in Rambling Rose.
Here, an overworked Dern walks in and out of corridors, drawing rooms, soundstages, continents and time as if she and the maestro know exactly what they rsquo;re doing without divulging their intentions to the audience. It rsquo;s moviegoers who must compromise their entertainment standards.
