Green Day With Three New Albums? | News @ Ultimate-Guitar.Com
Steven Bridge  |  by www.ultimate-guitar.com. All rights reserved. 23.04 | 16:19

The post reads: "Billie, Mike and Tre are back from summer vacations working hard on new material for the next Green Day album. Stay tuned for more news next week."
As previously reported by NME.

com in June, the band began working on dozens of ideas and demos for the new project, and have been calling the album "an event".
Billie Joe Armstrong told MTV: "At this point, to put a record out with like 12 songs on it and turn it in sounds a bit boring for us. So we want to definitely make something that is well thought out and (that) all of our blood is put into.

"
Quality over quantity, but Green Day have always been quality (I don't actually like them).

Billie Joe Armstrong told MTV: At this point, to put a record out with like 12 songs on it and turn it in sounds a bit boring for us. So we want to definitely make something that is well thought out and (that) all of our blood is put into.


Yeah right theyre just gonna do what they always do and find whatever is trendy' and popular and put it into an album and call it punk. Seriously the last album had absolutley no feel or emotion in it, they jsut wanted to get rich, and now they wanna get richer. I just wish they moved on to a different genre instead of bastardizing punk the way they are.

WTF? This is old news. But Im expecting maybe a double disk from Green Day and the 3rd CD will be The Network.

Yeah right theyre just gonna do what they always do and find whatever is trendy' and popular and put it into an album and call it punk. Seriously the last album had absolutley no feel or emotion in it, they jsut wanted to get rich, and now they wanna get richer. I just wish they moved on to a different genre instead of bastardizing punk the way they are.


Granted, American Idiot is a bit of a blip on their career, but Green Day are a rather good band with some great music. Stop flaming them because they're not as technical or as 'underground' as you like.
Awsome I've been a fan of Green Day for a long time, I can't wait till they release them lol.

..Green Day haven't really labeled themselves punk in a long ass time.

Its really just rock now. Stop bitching, its good music. Personally, I can't wait for the new album.

Its perfectly cool if you don't like them, just stop whining please because its annoying. None the less, I look forward to the album(s). awesome, i cant wait!

Unless of course the albums suck. I like the idea, as long as it doesn't turn out like Sandinista!, cus as much a Clash I am, that album isn't their greatest.


And people should stop moaning about them. Music is music, bands are gonna do what they want to do, weather it makes them music or not. I'm looking forward to the new album.

I hate people. People suck. They're always so negative and out to piss everyone off.

Why? What do you get out of it. I like Green Day, so please stop putting them down.

They create good, catchy little riffs and thats awesome. Later. I hate people.

People suck. They're always so negative and out to piss everyone off. Why?

What do you get out of it. I like Green Day, so please stop putting them down. They create good, catchy little riffs and thats awesome.

Later.


Powerchords should not count as riffs. You want riffs do you?

Go listen to Megadeth or Clutch! You want riffs, do you? Go listen to Megadeth or Clutch!


I don't want to. I like Green Day. I like music that you can hear what the singer is saying and have music that is good to listen to.

I don't want some guitars and some guy yelling in my ears. Later. i'm still hopeful for this album.

although it was one of their worst releases to date, american idiot wasn't bad compared to most music that gets onto top of the pops :-p
still, i hope at least some of the music takes a step backwards.
someone should let green day what the actual music community (not 12 year old girls) think of american idiot before they release an album building on it.
You want riffs, do you?

Go listen to Megadeth or Clutch!
I don't want to. I like Green Day.

I like music that you can hear what the singer is saying and have music that is good to listen to. I don't want some guitars and some guy yelling in my ears. Later.


yayyy megadeth yayyyyy! ..

. i blame the music media for categorizing bands because then it limits the bands into certain kinds of songs, good music is good music I keep saying the words Rip off if you like it, get it, if you don't, don't. What the **** is everyone's problems.

They don't effect you in any way, so why not bash something that is evedentally bad...

how aboutttt Locust? There you go, go bash them instead. Green Day is awesome.

I like their music, because is fun and energetic. I've played heavy metal before, it's so dark and depression and annoying. I'd rather sing then scream and I'd rather play 'American Idiot' then play a two chord metal song in Drop D.

Just stop with the flaming. Later. Your basing your argument on one song!

!!!

I didnt say all band scream down the mic!! i like all sorts of music, including some that have a bit of screaming!

!! I just making a point that people slate them coz there a bit commercial and not heavy enough!

!! If you dont like them then change the channel!

!! Besides be completely over played on the radio American Idiot was actually a great album.

I love almost all music from Led to Soundgarden to even Coldplay (some songs). American Idoit was a well developed album that really set new standers for green day. Compared to so much crap people call music it was good.

If you wanna here garbage sell outs in it for the money listen to the lost prophets new cd and then there old ones NOW THAT IS HORRIBLE! Either way they are great songwriters and deserve a little compassion. Hopefully they don't rush it and just put out a quality album(s).

The only thing I hope for their next album(s), is that they will stay away from trying to be political. I mean seriously! At first they try to be the most immature band ever, and then they want to express their political views?

I mean sure, everyone changes and matures over 10 years, but it's not like we were all waiting to here something from greenday that actually had a lot of meaning behind it (no I'm not being sarcastic). And sure they should change some from their dookie days, but that doesn't mean they have to be completely opposite. hahah.

.. that's so corny its funny.

.. anyways.

.. yeah.

.. they want so much money they should change their name to Greeday.

..
Kidding.

. in all seriousness, I don't understand why people hate them so much..

. I listen to metal and underground stuff..

real music.. not 3 powerchords.

. I'm so cool..

. blah..

. who cares? Yes, Greenday does use a lot (if not only) powerchords.

.. but guess what?

They were able to use powerchords so well that they made a couple of records and became rich and famous...

how many records have you released? How rich and famous are all you bashers?
Unless you're paying them to produce the album, let them do whatever they want.

..

Kidding.

. in all seriousness, I don't understand why people hate them so much..

. I listen to metal and underground stuff..

real music.. not 3 powerchords.

. I'm so cool..

. blah..

. who cares? Yes, Greenday does use a lot (if not only) powerchords.

.. but guess what?

They were able to use powerchords so well that they made a couple of records and became rich and famous...

how many records have you released? How rich and famous are all you bashers?
Unless you're paying them to produce the album, let them do whatever they want.

..


that's the best post I've read so far in here.

Yaay! so Greenday are sell-outs..

play easy power chords...

and don't scream as much as hardcore bands...

...

. who gives a rat's ass??

?
I would actually regain an ounce of respect for this band if they released a 3-disc set for the price of a single album.
Even if the music continues down the same bland pop-rock path they've been traveling for the last couple of albums.

Since we're on a guitar website, I guess it would only be appropriate for me to say that I really started playing guitar in the first place because of a certain group of bands, Green Day being one of them. By no means am I saying that the stuff that Green Day puts out as intricate as say Master of Puppets, but it's so much more fun to play when you're still learning. The music scene seems to be leaning toward the side of Punk music being dead, which may be true in some way, because most of the big punks names in music aren't really around anymore, and some, like Green Day, seem to still be lingering.

We've sort of moved into a much different music scene since when Dookie came out. I for one remember a time in music history where the really popular bands didn't even write their own music, whereas now, you can't do anything without some degree of original material. Say what you want about Green Day's lyrics writing ability, which in the 90's more often then not revolved around masturbation, but I found American Idiot to be something of a work of art.

There's an intricate story there that's not hard to find, and even without that, it's still fun to sing along to and try and learn how to play.
That's my 3 cents, I'm out.
It's not just metalheads, shred guitarists, or tru punks that hate them.

Stop the generalizing. There is no answer for why people dislike a band. Its all a matter of personal opinion.

As for screaming...

yes alot of metal has screaming/growls, but when your talking about the holocaust, or killing people are you going to softly sing it? No! Megadeth, Metallica, Judas Priest, Iron Maiden are all metal bands that do not scream.

Open your f**king ears. As for greenday, they are energetic and pretty decent song writters when they try (sure the topics don't apeal to me but w.e) I rather hear them on the radio then most rap (just my opinion).

One last thing about there riffs. Yes they are easy, look where they come from. They are not good musicians, and thats not needed when you come from a punk scene in S.

D. My two cents, i could write more but I need cloves. Lol, I agree with whoever said its now almost as 'trendy' to bash Greenday as to love them.


Personally, I still think they're ****ing amazing. Fine, so its all power chords, but if you think about it HOLY COW at how long they've gone with 3 power chords? (And although I like some metal stuff, I'd still rather listen to a song full of power chords than a 30-minute 'Holy shit, look at my solo skillzzz' guitar wank)
My neighbour is one of the best musicians I know, he plays Bass, and was playing at Degree levels at about 14-15.

Of course most of the music he listens to is 'technically-impressive',
Primus and the likes. Greenday are still one of his favourite bands.
Admittedly, I went off them for a while, after over-listening to American Idiot, they just got boring.

But then a few months ago I started listening again, and its still amazingly fun and listenable music.

Kidding..

in all seriousness, I don't understand why people hate them so much...

I listen to metal and underground stuff.. real music.

. not 3 powerchords..

I'm so cool...

blah...

who cares? Yes, Greenday does use a lot (if not only) powerchords..

. but guess what? They were able to use powerchords so well that they made a couple of records and became rich and famous.

.. how many records have you released?

How rich and famous are all you bashers?
Their music may not be hardcore and complex, but has another quality: it's simple enough to be understood and appreciated by a lot of people. I like some of their songs.

.. mainly the stuff I grew up with.

.. the new stuff, not as much, but still decent.

..
Unless you're paying them to produce the album, let them do whatever they want.

..
that's the best post I've read so far in here.


It's true. I mean, some people aren't here to actually say what they think. They're just giving their prejudice opinion to make themselves look stupid, like
greenday suck balls.

always have always will. dunno how they can still suck at their instruments.


Its a bit annoying.

I personally thought their last album was ok, it wasn't bad, but it wasn't nimrod or dookie. Im not even a big greenday fan. Heck, my favorite band is rush, the polar opposite of greenday, but hey, like some random post had said up in the middle they make good riffs, thats what matters .

Greenday does get old, but theres worse.
But yeah, lets hope they get less image like.
I laugh at all the kids on here that call Green Day talentless.

They've stayed true to a formula that works for them. People remember catchy short riffs or chord progressions. And they have quite of collection of songs that you could bust out anywhere that people would instantly recognize.

They don't follow the trends, they SET the trends. They've been in the spotlight for at least 15 years, how many pop/punk bands can say that? I didn't really care for American Idiot, but I still give respect where its due.

They're still one of the best concerts I have ever been to. sorry for 2x post, but also, when I say image like, I mean so political and so let me show you my ass so you forget about the music ordeal.

Green Day is awesome.

I like their music, because is fun and energetic. I've played heavy metal before, it's so dark and depression and annoying. I'd rather sing then scream and I'd rather play 'American Idiot' then play a two chord metal song in Drop D.

Just stop with the flaming. Later.


Name me a two chord METAL song in Drop D.

why dont you get it? They are just an awsome radio friendly band. Who cares if there not punk/ingenious or origional, its still awsome.

There just a harmless poppy band and always have been, same goes for FOB and all the other bands that have to suffer this tedious and arrogant flaming. Name me a 3 chord Greenday song?

I don't want to.

I like Green Day. I like music that you can hear what the singer is saying and have music that is good to listen to. I don't want some guitars and some guy yelling in my ears.

Later.


If you're referring to Megadeth when you said I don't want some guitars and some guy yelling my ears , then you're clearly mistaken because Megadeth doesn't scream.
Zakk Wylde likes Green Day, why can't you metalheads admit it too?

Why is everyone doubting Green Day on this one? I've yet to hear one album of their's that is not good. They always put out some great songs, and it's always more than one or two on each album.

None of you here can say that you didn't listen to their last album all the way through and not like at least two of their songs. Billie Joe is a great lyricist too. At least they're not gay asses like MCR!

I never said Greenday only had 3 chord songs. I was just wondering if you knew of a Metal song with only two chords in Drop D. Because I've honestly never heard one.


I don't necessarily like greenday, but my band covered a few of their songs just cos they're crowd-pleasers and fun to play.
I'm not into the whole bashing thing, and I can't say whether they are bringing out 3 albums just for money or not and neither can any of you. Why?

cos for one you haven't even heard the albums yet.
I think what I'm trying to say has been said at least 5 times over already by someone else. So in short, just cos they are punk and have DEVELOPED their sounds over the years.

. yes developed not totally changed it and sold out like a lot of you seem to think. Look at Metallica.

. think they haven't sold out? hmm.

green day are always gonna be the best band in the world. they are also always gonna be the best live band in the world they make fantastic music and american idiot wasnt the best album theyve done but it was good personily i cant wait for there next work of art. rock on dudes(only doodes hu love green day)x To what the above guy said about selling out.

. yeah..

. I think any band that plans to make it or stick around has to sell out at one point or another, even if it's just a little bit..

. that's how the music business seems to work..

. ideals about being true to the music and whatnot are admirable and optimistic, but realistically (and unfortunately), signed bands are in a business like any other business..

. have you got any news that isn't from last year ? I lost interest in these guys after American Idiot.

Ive got their International Superhits cd and its great, all the Green Day I need. Longview has one of the best basslines Ive ever heard Ooh smoking pot is what Green Day is all about and it's 420. Maybe UG knew this.

.. green days washed up.

they have a little imo, steal moms eyeliner fan base and greenday looks just like those little kids. i hate when bands try and keep themselves in the spotlight when people dont want them there. and they probly just pay out alot of money to radio stations so we have to hear them every 4th song.

please, give us some variety, and not as in 3 cds. as in different bands. give it a rest greenday Eww!

International Superhits...

That's like saying you like Queen and only buying their greatest hits. And you talk about Green Day being poppy punk star sellouts. Well you just helped them sellout.

WTF? This is old news. But Im expecting maybe a double disk from Green Day and the 3rd CD will be The Network.


Yeah I read it ages ago and that's what I imagined. After all they said that they had three different types of things in the making, described roughly as: a straight-up punk album, a weird new wave type thing, and a sort of epic American Idiot style record. The new wave one'll be the network's release.

By the way, morons, they don't claim to be punk. They haven't been since Dookie and Kerplunk, and never say they are. So stop accusing them of bastardising punk.

Just because poser kids think they're listening to punk with Green Day, doesn't mean it's the band's fault. I lost interest in these guys after American Idiot. Ive got their International Superhits cd and its great, all the Green Day I need.

Longview has one of the best basslines Ive ever heard
Eww! International Superhits..

. That's like saying you like Queen and only buying their greatest hits. And you talk about Green Day being poppy punk star sellouts.

Well you just helped them sellout.
What? I never said they were sellouts, I just dont like American Idiot.

People here go mental over nothing, you are one of them thats cool, as long as they dont suck. Oh it already has gotten old. A LONG TIME AGO!


Personally, I don't care about Green Day's music but I know alot of chica's who will be buying this album. So Green Day's gonna get rich off of this one. They probably wanted to do the double album thing, but then thought Hey, how about we do 3 instead .

But yeah, as long as it's good I don't care. They're loaded. Why the hell would they be be thinking 3 albums = 3x $ ?

They grew up broke off their asses; they aren't freaking Paris Hilton or a random pop star, they're just musicians who hit it big. Meaning blood pumps through their veins just like ours, not cash-money like some people would believe.
And how can you say Green Day just jump on whatever trend is out?

American Idiot STARTED a trend, if anything. You're accusing them of making Green Day-esque music because Green Day-esque music got popular..

. completely ignoring the fact that they ARE Green Day, and that the Green Day sound has changed every record since their inception.
The only anti-Bush sentiment on the ENTIRE ALBUM was during the track Holiday, which was one track out of over a solid hour of music.

Unless you're counting the song American Idiot, where if you had any reading comprehension abilities whatsoever you'd already know it has nothing to do with the government and everything to do with trying to find your own identity without being duped by TV and the media in an age where images and advertisments and propaganda are being thrown in your face everywhere you look. That's what the whole CD is about.
I'd appreciate it if people would stop ripping on bands without knowing the facts just because it pisses them off that other people like music that they have decided is lame.


In other words, they're pissed off and jealous that Billie Joe Armstrong can put a song on top of the Billboard charts for 13 weeks with 5 barre chords, and the crappy-ass boring as hell prog rock band they spew on about will never place on a chart because no one wants to listen to 6 guys jerking off their instruments for 10 minutes at a time. THAT ain't music.
Although.

...

Um...

Good for them. Sounds a little like 'Use Your Illusion' +1. Either that, or they can't be arsed with cutting the lame songs.

how many double disc albums can you say are good from start to finish. i can't think of any. guns n roses use your illusions are probably the closest but that could have definately been condensed to one album.

maybe green day will suprise me but i dont think any band could pull off three. there just doing it to be different and most of it will probably appear to be filler. i like them, but this doesnt sound promising!

not makin a record but akin an event, screams to me sell as much greenday products as possible still ill keep a full open mind! if the music is good who cares! I think that the fact of the matter is that they will not release 3 albums as this article is very speculation based, I think that anyone bashing them for american idiot can shut up because they had a huge cultural impact with that album.

..you don't believe me?

Why are you replying to this article then?
At any rate I reckon green day will come out with something pretty sweet.
i hate when people say green day sold out.

they were never a punk band to begin with. I would just like to say that the red hot chili peppers (my favorite band) had the same intention of bringing out 3 albums in one year because they had so much material they wanted to use, but they were convinced by warner bros their label to just bring out a double album, needless to say on the singles from stadium arcadium there are some really good b sides, so green day say they're bringing out three albums lets just see what happens, don't forget quantity doesn't necessarily mean quality. A little hard for them to come off of Summer break when it's mid-Spring.

Who's to say they can't have a summer vacation when it isn't summer. They are rich and famous. Why does everyone on this entire site suck RHCP's dick.

If you think Green Day is repetitive with their chord's well so is RHCP when it comes to making songs about California. 1st Album: Style of Kerplunk, 10,000 Hours, etc.
2nd album: Conglomeration of stuff from Dookie up to American Idiot.


3rd Album: Something new that will blow us all away.
Who else thinks that would be a badass idea?
I hope they sound good and not exactly as their previous ones.

Look - I hate greenday as much as the next guy who can't stand greenday, and I think that releasing three albums is a stupid publicity stunt, but they're doing something right in the world of music, or they wouldn't be around for so long. If something sucks, it's going to die out, but greenday's been around since the 90s. You don't like em, fine, but don't be a bitch and talk shit for no reason.

.

At this point, to put a record out with like 12 songs on it and turn it in sounds a bit boring for us. So we want to definitely make something that is well thought out and (that) all of our blood is put into.


So we are going to release 36 songs on 3 albums that all sound the same and sell them for three times the cost.
After american idiot Green Day is dead to me.
first, any band that makes it big is undoubtedly going to face criticism.

people hate it when someone else succeeds.
i personally think that american idiot was a crappy album.
i wrote green day's epitaph after shenanigans which in my opinion was their final album.

i regret buying american idiot and am certainly not going to buy this three disk set. mt first ever cd was nimrod, which might have been their best album.
also to you who said there was no 3 chord green day song if i remember right warning is just C A G repeated over and over.

and yes i like that song
lol @ UG starting to post Green Day articles every Friday again.
Where did he actually say three albums? It didn't really say anything about that in the article, and they even said get ready for the next album, singular.

I don't get it.
Personally, I'd rather hear Green Day than Justin Timberlake or a lot of that other shit out there. If anything, I'm looking forward to new Green Day to steal some air time.

That's probably all they'll manage considering that when they make one album, half the songs sound like filler...

let alone three albums. From a marketing standpoint, Greenday will gain much more profit from selling the 3 albums seperately at diferent times. Despite some of the selling out that has somewhat gone on from the band, I still admire Green Day for their passion and their ability to still rock.

I give them much respect. Yeah right theyre just gonna do what they always do and find whatever is trendy' and popular and put it into an album and call it punk. Seriously the last album had absolutley no feel or emotion in it, they jsut wanted to get rich, and now they wanna get richer.

I just wish they moved on to a different genre instead of bastardizing punk the way they are.
No emotion in it? Are you kidding me?

You definitley haven't listened to that album.
Anyway, I like them, I liked American Idiot, and I look forward to these. I think it's pretty funny how a lot of people liked it when it first came out, but then once it got really popular everyone started hating it for the sake of it.

He only said they were releasing AN album...

where are the other two mentioned? Green Day is one of my favorite bands in the world. I'm sitting here wondering how anyone could dislike them.

..but then I remember to each his own .


So if the entire world goes against Green Day and no one buys their album except for me, then so be it. I will be listening to them no matter what.
But the next time someone makes fun of me for listening to emo shit I'm gonna have to shoot them.

They are a rock band, leave it at that.
Try imagining being in the band's place right now.
Why does everyone on this entire site suck RHCP's dick.

If you think Green Day is repetitive with their chord's well so is RHCP when it comes to making songs about California.
You don't like the Red hot Chili Peppers fair enough but you can't say it's crap or repetitive. Despite the fact that they are almost entirely talentless, you HAVE to give them credit for making it as far as they have with such limited ability.

Granted, American Idiot is a bit of a blip on their career, but Green Day are a rather good band with some great music. Stop flaming them because they're not as technical or as 'underground' as you like.
Now I'm gonna try and explain my thougts of the Green day issue.

I like green day, I liked their old stuff and I thoguht American Idiot was a godd album. not as good as Dookie, but very good. But every one keeps saying American Idiot was a shitty album .

No it wasn't, I specifically remember EVERYONE liking it at first. but then American Idiot songs got to be big MTV hits . its not their fault they got pushed to the top of the alt rock, punk trend a couple years ago, but thats because the album was so well liked all across the board.

and then people like this IE the I like the old green day stuff but American Idiot sucks! When in reality they liked it, but when Everyone liked it, it went from your album to that jock *****s album, to the preppy bitch we all hate, that boss who gets on your case, he liked it to. we didn't have our Green day.

But something tells me, this ( or these) cd wont be big, and everyone will go oh I kinda like Green day again . The last Cd wasn't a push to get money it was kinda like the Black Album of punk. Green day is Arguably the most recognizable punk band on earth, and Just like Metallica in the 90's, Had one huge album that made them a bajillion( yes Bajillion) new trend fans, and alienated those fans who liked them before.

So in short they were the biggest thing for a while, they'll go back to being the soem where in the middle again soon, where we all liked them, so stop with the green day hating.
well, if you are going to compare green day with metallica, you would have to look at the track record of metallica.
they got huge with the black album, alienated their fans, and never got many of them back.

just go to any metallica thread and read the pre-black, post-black, all cd's arguments.
so if green day follows metallica, then they will not go back to being the green day people apparantly loved so much, and will continue more in the vein of American Idiot.
personally, I like some green day, and can't deny they can right a hook, but I prefer guitar player music, with the occasional guilty pleasures of simple bands.

green day not one of them. i am intrigued by the three cd idea. anyone think they are going to write a three disc rock opera that coincides with a release with a movie and some comic books?

=p who gives a shit if all they play is 3 chords all the time. they're probably THE most famous band out there right now. I live in So Cal and i think at least one of their songs is played on every ****in radio station every day.

even the classic rock station out here. they play their old stuff and their new stuff. and wuts the point of being in a band?

? to get popular. if they can write stuff ppl like, THAT'S talent.

get over urselves you stupid ****s. Hey look 12 year olds can play 3 new singles constantly for the next year then forget spaces in their favorite bands Greenday and Fallout Boy. w0rd.

This will be bomb, and maybe people won't piss themselves in frustration because they sold out . I can see why they would release 3 cd's.
They cant recognize when they sound terrible, and when they actually pull off a good song, so they release 3 times the material in hopes of realeasing 5-6 good songs out of 36, instead of 2 out of 12.


And this thread is so ridiculous, that you SHOULD take this seriously.
who gives a shit if all they play is 3 chords all the time. they're probably THE most famous band out there right now.

I live in So Cal and i think at least one of their songs is played on every ****in radio station every day. even the classic rock station out here. they play their old stuff and their new stuff.

and wuts the point of being in a band?? to get popular.

if they can write stuff ppl like, THAT'S talent. get over urselves you stupid ****s.
Actually, the point in being a band is to play music.

Getting popular is only the goal of people who just want to get rich quick. Music that's deep and has meaning to it is the goal of a band, and trust me, I'm in my own indie band right now, plenty of the bands in the scene around here all write some good stuff, that's what being in a band is about, not getting rich. But to stay on topic here, I think it's a marketing ploy, and I was a huge fan of their really old stuff (39/Smooth era) but while I enjoyed American Idiot, it got boring fast.

p.s maybe this time they'll put 4 chords instead of 3..

because they said they want to do something better...

. thats an improvement..

. sry for double posting..

Dude seriously even though Green Day is one of my favorite bands the people commenting hear defending Green Day are sooo annoying it almost makes me embarassed to like Green Day. Why does everyone who likes a simple band that gets dissed decide that they need to insult metal? What's wrong with metal?

And what's wrong with Green Day? For everyone that says Green Day is not talented, listen to the bass. Mike Dirnt is a really good bass player, and just because you don't show off, doesn't mean you suck.


And if everyone would turn off their radio and turn off their tv, they would appreciate Green Day a lot more.
For everyone that says Green Day is not talented, listen to the bass. Mike Dirnt is a really good bass player, and just because you don't show off, doesn't mean you suck.


I don't think this/these album(s) are going to be what everyone thinks they will be. Because if you listen to every Green Day album, none of them are alike, with the exception of the first two. Each of them has a different feel.


And if everyone would turn off their radio and turn off their tv, they would appreciate Green Day a lot more.

So what if they write 3 chord songs. It's not about how awesome the guitar part is.

It's all about the MUSIC. Sure, I got to admit that their songs are very easy to play and I learned the guitar parts in a few minutes. But Green Day pulled the 3 chord notation off really well.

Music doesn't have to be so complex to be so great. I dont like Green Day or rabid Green Day fans, therefore i will not buy one two, or even three albums because frankly im tired of hearing them, hey Billie or whatever way you spell your name, go learn to play guitar, and Tre Cool, your not cool at all especially for changing your name to cool, and bass player guy, i have no qualm with you, because i have yet to learn your name, **** your Green Day and your cause and u shouldnt bash America, for it is the very country that made you rich, so in a way you are right, Americans are idiots, at least for the most part, the rest of us have functioning ears and listen to music becuase its good and not because of it being popular, that is all take my message and do with it what you will, looking forward to the new Metallica album sincerely, pissed off single minded Metal Head, write a song about that, also Greed Day is wayy too overplayed and i know its not in their control but its annoying thats why i hate greenday.The music isnt good and the 3 power chord gets annoying as hell.

Id rather listen to something with some awesome instrument work rather then the same crap every song. and i call bullshit. There's only gonna be one.


Thats how all these bands work. They put up a bunch of material and half gets left on the cutting floor. They'll come out with one album, with what they consider to be the best songs.

Somebody must be broke, cause all I can think of is greed
someone should let green day what the actual music community (not 12 year old girls) think of american idiot before they release an album building on it.

Don't speak for the entire music community when you say things like that. I'm a 17 year old boy.

I listen to Marilyn Manson and Nine Inch Nails. I listen to Korn and Rage against the Machine. I listen to AC/DC and Nirvana.

I listen to Alice and Chains and U2. I listen to Black Sabbath and the Red Hot Chili Ppers.
American Idiot is in my top ten albums.

Don't assume only 12 year old girls liked American Idiot . True, a lot did because of the anti-Bush bandwagon and they thought Billie was cute, but American Idot is still a good piece of musical work that they put a lot of effort into.
Furthermore, an artist shoud never take into account how the rest of the community felt about one of their pieces.

Making art is about making what you want, not what someone else wants. Get over it. They are punk rock.

At least in part. Not in the same sense as The Sex Pistols or The Clash (even though if you start listening to those bands, you realize there's a lot of really poppy stuff). Punk is indefinable because it really has so many elements.

A lot of those elements can be found in Green Day's music (and don't say they're not, because we all know that most of the people here who would disagree don't listen to Green Day enough to know).
And for the record, qhy are you guys so pissed off over them always playing three chords ? I find it ironic that you're complaining about all these short power chord progressions, and then you go and listen to Nirvana or Black Sabbath.

Lol, the drummer in my (metal) band used to be obssessed with these guys. Couldn't really figure it out, him playing metal but loving a pop-punk/rock band..

. why cant people just like what they like and accept that no one ever will have exactly the same musical taste as another person?
and i cant see how any one can call a band as big as greenday cr*p, as if they were cr*p they wouldnt be where they are today.


rather than slagging off bands and people for what music they listen to, just do what guitarists should be doing and make your own music.
thats just what i think anyways.
wow, if people are gonna aruge if they hate the new shit a band puts out, or argue that they are getting tired of the old formula that made them like it in the first place, or just coming to bash about how good a band was before they sold out
wow, a lot of angry people here
seriously if you dont like green day then dont read the article and leave, flaming a band just because they aren't your thing is stupid
anyway, i think ill be looking forward to this when it comes out
lmao thats so true haha.


but dude, three albums at once? thats the worst idea ive ever heard. people arent gonna know which one to buy unless they deliberately make one better than the others, and thats stupid too.

the materials gonna get no individual attention at all, its even worse than a double album, cuz you cant buy them all together.
im not gonna get into bashing them just because they arent some tech metal meets dream theater meets led zeppelin band with tons of talent because thats for losers who have no lives, but thats an absolutely terrible idea.
green day sucks, learn how to solo Billie Joe.

That crap in holiday or american idiot doesnt count as a solo either btw.
Listen to 1039 and Kerplunk, retard I play guitar! I like guitar!

I don't really judge music so much on the intricacies but rather what my ear tells me. If it has a guitar,I'll listen. GD were more like punk but, not hardcore.

Good is good. All the bands always mentioned are at least good
that was after they sold out . But, who gives a ****.

Whoever said washed up, what the **** are you talking about. pretty successful album and tour. The album was not all about bashing bush, I was a reflection of pop culture and all the idiots don't get it - because you are who they're talking about.

I loved learning guitar to green day, circle jerks and all those catchy powerchord stuff. I may have quit if my first song was master of puppets. I don't listen much anymore and i have progressed to Metallica and pantera (just a couple examples).

When I get stuck in a rut I'll play along with a couple GD albums. It's just fun. Is it okay to play guitar and have fun?

Greenday actually reminds me of rockabilly in the 50's like budy holly. I'm only here because I'm still at work. in 45 minutes i'll be hittin the bong playing guitar and forget all this B.

S. Shut up and play, It's 420 punk, enjoy! No shit.

Even if they release three albums over a three year period, they're still making the same amount of money.
Not bad news, Green Day isn't terrible. All I can say to the biased metalheads is if your favorite band was as popular as Green Day, would they be sell-outs ?

You preach and preach yet if they were ever as popular you would probably say you don't like them anymore ala Metallica. Though I love Metallica up to the black album. Furthermore, an artist shoud never take into account how the rest of the community felt about one of their pieces.

Making art is about making what you want, not what someone else wants. Get over it.
hhaahaha.

do you REALLY believe that green day is playing what they like???

they are the most blatently sold out band in the industry. I'm just hoping as a hardcore Green Day fan that this is going to be a lot better than American Idiot. Old fans will recognize Dookie through Warning for the genius they was.


And yes, American Idiot did indeed have a plot line, although I do admit it sucked a little.
i dont seem to understand why people dislike bands with any political over tones seriously they're people they live in the same world they can have politcial opinions.On top of that open ur friggin minds and stop whining about what is and what isn't punk rock or metal or ****in folk seriously if it sounds good shut up and go with it .

if u dont like it thats fine to dont ruin it for everybody else i swear to god if my band ever gets anywhere im gonna flame/rant/seriously kick the crap out of as many bandwagon music fans as possible cuz all this negaitivty surrounding music needs to end.Also anybody who says they dont get into the music industry to get rich and rip you off is a ****ing liar.i dont understand that either the minute a band gets famous and starts making millions they sold out **** you they need to eat they need to live they have the talent to be rich they deserve just like baseball and football players they have talent they use it to get rich so stop whining and shut the **** up.

u whiney little goth homos.also greenday isnt the first band to wear make up anybody forget about kiss,alice cooper most of the metal and glam bands of the 80's. Im 21 years old and im pretty sure all the flaming is coming from immature faggoty 14-17 yr olds that just got into music and listen to other so called music affciandos of the same age shut up and do ur home work and go to bed
1.

ROFL. when you say bandwagon fans greenday is the first thing that comes to mind.
2.

these days, it's not what you know, but who you know. greenday has NO pure musical talent, they simply play what is popular. they made it big because they knew the right people and they must have had some knowledge of the industry.

You say they made it big because of their extremely talented power chord banging? haha, that was TOTALLY taken out of context! i read this, what they actually said was that they were working on Three seperate ideas for albums.

...

and they havnt decided on which will be the new album yet. Not my cup of tea, I think they're horrible. so a double album wasn't enough so they're kicking it up a notch?

hhaahaha. do you REALLY believe that green day is playing what they like??

? they are the most blatently sold out band in the industry.
Metallica hasnt even reached Greenday status yet.

.. Greenday sold it out huge man.

.. but what do i care, i dont like punk, pop-punk, emo, hardcore, or wtf ever.

its straight Metal baby . and i mean real metal.

Sabbath, Pantera, Maiden, Priest. thats where the talent is and thats where im stayin so in my final words..

. FUCK GREENDAY and about the 2 note metal song..

Walk by Pantera is 2 notes, and that song kicks major ass. much more than greenday ever will haha I love how you are all saying the album(s) suck before they've even ****ing recorded it. Great job everyone!

You all suck, Green Day are WAY more talented than anyone who has posted here. Don't even argue that, it's not possible. THEY ARE MORE TALENTED THAN YOU.

Now, seeing as how most of you say they suck...

what does that make you? If you don't like Green Day, then piss off and don't post in forums/threads/news about them and go post in whatever bands news/threads that you like.
Anyways, can't wait for the new stuff.


well put, if you don't like greenday why the hell are you bitching and whineing about it on a story about greenday screw off no one want's to hear that people
I nicely ask you all to stop putting Green Day down, but it's like talking to a wall. Just stop. Read articles on the bands that you LIKE.

Like anyone wants to hear you put down there favorite band. I don't go and bash bands that I don't like. I read articles on bands that I LIKE.

Later. insomniac is one of the greatest punk records ever, go take a listen. If you don't have anything nice to say, don't say anything at all.

- Every mother I have ever met
Some of you should take this advice and compose your comments with maturity.
i may not listen to green day often but 3 albums would be cool, 3 times the music for the fans to get excited over and for big green day fans, more songs to perform on the road. I'm sorry, but it pisses me off how they think they're right about everything, especially political shit.

You be President when 9/11 happens, then write about how much you ****ed up. If you hate Bush that much over stupid-ass ****ing shit, keep it to yourself and not make a huge over-dramatized deal about it. Honestly, I dont get why you guys hate them because their more successful than two or three of your death metal bands put together.

...

I cant wait for the new albums to come out, today when my brother told me about this, I honestly almost wet my pants because GD's that awesome.
Oh yeah and also, what is the point in being a musician that dosen't make any money? You have to sell out sooner or later, unless you want to end up being a cashier at Wal-Mart (no offense to all the good people that are cashiers).

I'd WAY rather make music and get paid, then make music and get paid 500 bucks for a gig (before you split it with your bandmates...

.)
And if you dont like Green Day..

...

THEN QUIT READING GREEN DAY'S NEWS!!!

!
Wow. Compose your comments with maturity and keep your negative comments to yourself.

That's all I ask, put people just enjoying being mean and dumb. I just don't get it. I meant to say I dont hate rednecks.


Yeah and Insomniac is one of the greatest punk records ever.
Honestly, I dont get why you guys hate them because their more successful than two or three of your death metal bands put together..

..I cant wait for the new albums to come out, today when my brother told me about this, I honestly almost wet my pants because GD's that awesome.


Oh yeah and also, what is the point in being a musician that dosen't make any money? You have to sell out sooner or later, unless you want to end up being a cashier at Wal-Mart (no offense to all the good people that are cashiers). I'd WAY rather make music and get paid, then make music and get paid 500 bucks for a gig (before you split it with your bandmates.

...

)
And if you dont like Green Day...

..THEN QUIT READING GREEN DAY'S NEWS!

!!!


All of you rednecks go away and quit hating an awesome band. Here's an idea, kill all of your brain cells and listen to your metal and stuff while watching mosquitos get zapped by a bug-zapper and wonder why you have no friends, life, or taste in music.
I dont rednecks or metal, I just hate the two together.


really? because of one southern band (whom i don't even like) your going to associate rednecks and metal, dude metal is much more than just detuned guitars and pinch harmonics being uselessy wasted. thats what i call sh!

t metal. real metal is an amazing thing and it beats the hell outa green day, for a band who complains about sellouts they pretty much win then hypocracy award..

.
i can't believe they even have 3 albums worth of ideas left in their talentless 3 chord band..

. lol..

.Green Day haven't really labeled themselves punk in a long ass time. Its really just rock now.

Stop bitching, its good music. Personally, I can't wait for the new album. Its perfectly cool if you don't like them, just stop whining please because its annoying.


Have you seen bullet in a bible? They say its the biggest show in the history of punk rock
Their old stuff was kinda punk, and it definitely was rock. And they did play lots of the old stuff.


And for everybody else...


Don't bash Green Day if you don't like them. If you hate them because they are doing a trend, then you're just following the trend of bashing guys who you think sell out. Maybe they just like that kind of music, right?

They have great lyrics if you listen too. And I can imagine myself up there playing all those Green Day songs having one hell of a fun time. So if you don't like 'em go to the column w/ Ozzy in it.

Not that I particularly like them a lot, but they are good songwriters. And (for the shred noobs to stop saying 'd00d lawl blowj0b armstrong gatz no skillzz') Paul Gilbert likes 'em for their creativity in that area.
Wtf?

Are you retarded? Stop trying to make shitty excuses. ur just doin it to follow the trend of bashin bandz that sel out
How about this one.

They did sell out, their music is about money, there is no trend in bashing them, they suck and are labelling themselves something absolutely stupid...

I can't even be bothered to point out all the stupid things they do. But everyone has a legitimate reason to be bashing them, so don't try make up stupid shit. For some reason Im looking forward to this.

1991: Metallica release The Black Album (their biggest album to date), tour for several years, release a tour video/DVD, then come back with enough material for several albums.
2004: Green Day release American Idiot (their biggest album to date), tour for several years, release a tour DVD, then come back with enough material for several albums.
In conclusion, you shouldn't be worried about these albums, but the next studio album after.


*thinks of St. Anger and shudders* Sorry for double post, but to stick directly to the subject, i am a fan (not huge) and will buy these albums, but what i'll do is wait to see which album people say is the best and pick that one. Why is everyone doubting Green Day on this one?

I've yet to hear one album of their's that is not good. They always put out some great songs, and it's always more than one or two on each album. None of you here can say that you didn't listen to their last album all the way through and not like at least two of their songs.

Billie Joe is a great lyricist too. At least they're not gay asses like MCR!
Yes, but MCR have an exceptional guitarist (Ray), as well as Frank.


MCR do have good guitarists but are you saying Billie Joe isn't good as a guitarist? I would say all of the above aren't that great but I know I want to be alone on 1039 Smoothed out Slappy Hours is a much more challenging song to play than any MCR song I have ever heard. Not to mention he is singing while playing guitar.

Green Day rocks! Weezer even says so. I don't want to.

I like Green Day. I like music that you can hear what the singer is saying and have music that is good to listen to. I don't want some guitars and some guy yelling in my ears.

Later.
If you're referring to Megadeth when you said I don't want some guitars and some guy yelling my ears , then you're clearly mistaken because Megadeth doesn't scream.
where do you get megadeth from that?

! Where did we get this idea that Green Day is not Punk. They came from nothing, toured in people's houses, while doing lots of drugs, they don't care too much for the gov't, and they've practiced what they preached.

Why are we even putting band's in genre's and what is up with these new bands creating their own genres like 'postmodern punk elite rap' or something. Genres suck! Green Day Rocks!

How about this one. They did sell out, their music is about money, there is no trend in bashing them, they suck and are labelling themselves something absolutely stupid..

.I can't even be bothered to point out all the stupid things they do. But everyone has a legitimate reason to be bashing them, so don't try make up stupid shit.


if they did sell out, it was back in 1994 when they went from a small punk label to a big label and released dookie
considering they haven't changed label, how did they sell out? hm?
they wanted to make a political album, it was a success.

...

no selling out here
you dont like green day, fair enough but dont make up crap that isn't true just because you dont like them Their albums will overshadow eachother. They should stagger the releases by a year. Then each album will be viewed individually.


The flipside is, if they release them all at once then maybe each single will get less airplay, and we won't get as sick of the songs.
Actually, it wasn't even a political album. The only political song was Holiday.


And hasn't every band that anyone's ever heard of sold out in some way? That how you expand your music to other people.
People can be so shallow.

Okay, some of you people I swear to god are retarded. Half of you faggots are saying Green day uses C5 and G5 and D5 and A5' and whatever the hell else. Duh.

Wonderwall uses E and G and D and A. Does that make that song suck? Soem of the beatles songs use those very same chords.

Some Rolling Stones songs like Satisfaction use riffs with fewer notes than that. Who cares as long as the songs are good? And you people that bash them?

First off, many many artists are becoming political. They have songs that say what they believe. It's called freedom of speech faggot.

They can say what they want, when they want, and American Idiot got them on top of the world again. The biggest song off of that album was boulevard of broken dreams, which had nothing to do with politics.
I hate people.

People suck. They're always so negative and out to piss everyone off. Why?

What do you get out of it. I like Green Day, so please stop putting them down. They create good, catchy little riffs and thats awesome.

Later.
Powerchords should not count as riffs. You want riffs do you?

Go listen to Megadeth or Clutch!
Are you ****ing kidding me? Megadeth?

Clutch? Satan worshipping bands that scream as loud as hell with homosexual songs? Are you insane?

Once Megadeth gets 60,000 people in another coutnry to see them, come tlak to me.
Okay, who do you like? Green Day doesn't do what is trendy or popular.

They make music they love, like American Idiot, which was the Punk rock opera and people ending up liking it. And btw. No feel or emotion?

With songs about his dad dying, what they feel about politics, and the personal songs that told stories, they don't have emotion? You can go back with the other Megadeth faggot fan and listen to some Marilyn Manson you ****ing queen. I like the occasional Greenday song, good for them doing what they want to do.

I mean think about it wouldn't it be kind of weird for them to come off of the success of American Idiot and just make a normal album. Hopefully it wont suck. You never know.

Haha! It's so true! Twist of Cain can totally join them!

eh, good for them for being ambitious, but a lot of double/multiple albums recently haven't turned out that well. Most people are shitting on Green Day because of the huge spotlight there in, when in fact they really don't make amazing music. Catchy?

Yes. Appealing to mainstream crowd? Yes.

Technical, more creative and intricate then many other unnoticed band? Absolutely not. Broaden your musical horizons a bit.

There's more to music then a chord progression and a catchy melody. oh, i saw a glimpse of a comment that included something about The Network. that would be epic.

maybe some Pinhead Gunpowder? correct me if i'm wrong, but i never have seen any comment about Green Day calling themselves punk. that's what people today think of their old stuff and they assume that because their new material is different, they are trying to regain their 'punk'.


i give it a Thumb's Up to the new material.
oh, i havn't bothered to look just yet, but if there is a comment bashing them about their obvious disapproval of the government stated in Idiot, i'm sure they wouldn't say the same about these bands.
prolly coz there a shitty no talent band that gets famous because because of some power chords and and makeup that they wear.

...

i just assume anyways
ok. one more comment, then i'm done.
it's interesting the reasons why you dislike Green Day.

power chords and makeup. i want you to name three good bands that really don't use power chords. and the makeup, please, it's the the 21st century and you're hardcore .

that's pretty much you. it might not be my personal liking, but everyone wears makeup. probably half the bands you enjoy listening to wear makeup.

and play power chords.
You should get your facts straight before you bash a band. Dave Mustaine(Singer/Songwriter for Magadeth) is a christian not a satan worshiper.

They have sold millions of records worldwide and sell-out almost every concert. Mustaine does not scream and he is considered one of the best guitar players worldwide not just Heavy Metal. his lyrics are socially and politicaly relevant to issues around the world.


Clutch can blow a goat though.
Greenday has a talent for writing catchy POP songs that apeal to the masses. There is nothing wrong with that as long as Greenday is ok with it.


There is so much wasted energy on hating music you don't like. If you don't like it leave it alone. Move on to something you do like.

I hate their music, without powerchords they would be nothing. All they know is powerchords. Green Day bought and has been buying into for a long time what people want to hear.

the 90s was all into being messed up, now its all about anti bush, and why the us gov is messed up, and how they do nothing about it but write cheap lyrics and make money. they are pop, they give u want u wana hear, get used to it Granted, American Idiot is a bit of a blip on their career, but Green Day are a rather good band with some great music.

Read more on by www.ultimate-guitar.com. All rights reserved.
Keywords: American Idiot, Three Albums, Billie Joe, Their Music, Black Album, International Superhits, Long Time, Billie Joe Armstrong, Red Hot Chili, Heavy Metal
Related news
Post comments
Name
Place
1 + 9 =
Comments